NYX Collection Noir Skinny Black Liner

I am absolutely horrid at doing an eyeliner look, especially when it comes to using a liquid liner. I very much prefer twist-up liner application. Hence, I was understandably elated to chance upon this product at a Sephora outlet in Singapore. The word "skinny" just really captured my attention and interest - It is something different, at least in my books. I was keeping my fingers crossed that this skinny liner can give me a thin and precise, almost liquid liner look, but with way easier control during application. However, after purchasing it and giving it a go, I realised that the colour payoff was not intensely black enough and the line drawn on with this liner was not thin nor clean-cut enough. I was naturally disappointed. This cost me SGD$11 so it was quite a bargain. Nevertheless, I will not recommend nor re-purchase.